Dating Someone Opening Their Marriage
Dating someone opening their marriage? Learn why getting involved in their marital drama crosses important boundaries that protect everyone.
My husband and I are currently in an open marriage and it’s been going well and we’ve been communicating really beautifully. We see a couples therapist and also do our own inpidual therapy.
I met someone and made a wonderful connection. He is in the very nascent stages of opening his marriage. His partner has never really been interested. It has come up in their relationship multiple times over the last decade, and now because of his feelings for me they are in the discussion again.
She agreed to try and they created some agreements and boundaries, and it was going well for a moment. However, she is now not feeling safe with the lifestyle choice. She’s dealing with fears of inadequacy and losing her relationship. He feels like in his excitement to transition he brought up too many concepts too quickly and didn’t allow her enough time to process.
I’m not quite sure what to do. It feels as though he’s trying not to lose me and not to lose his marriage, but it doesn’t really feel like they are aligned in lifestyle. And that may be what’s truly happening here and I need to step away.
Are these types of situations common and how does one navigate these transitions in a way that feels fair to all involved ?
Thank you so much for all that you do.
Struggling to mange your emotions in polyamory? My workshop, Following the Thread is now available on Teachable.
It’s extremely common for people to be introduced to non-monogamy and want to try it while they are already in a monogamous relationship. I would say that is more common than not and truly I do not think there is a perfect way to introduce the topic within a monogamous marriage. I sort of reject the assumption that “going slow” makes things easier because I often think that it reinforces the idea that one can control the uncontrollable, but I absolutely understand the desire people have to do it this way.
In your particular case, what worries me is how much you know about this situation and how involved you are. You have absolutely no control over your metamour and to be honest, I don’t know if your partner or prospective partner has actually really disclosed to his wife how much detail he is giving you about their relationship.
It’s a little bit of an invasion of her privacy for you to know so much information without being someone like a therapist who has no skin in this game and has professional boundaries. With your prospective partner being new to non-monogamy it makes sense that he is unaware of these boundaries and is probably telling you all of this because he has not yet learned how to take responsibility for his own choices, but I think it’s also important for you to learn when to say no to too much information.
While he may feel subject to the whims of his partner, he is a grown adult. He is ultimately making these choices and he needs to own them rather than telling you all of the details about how he is walking on eggshells around his wife. It is fully possible for him to own his choices and communicate to you clearly how much time he is able to give and that he fully intends on prioritising his wife without involving you in the emotional push and pull of what’s going on unnecessarily. And it is also possible for you to say no to these details. He may not fully realise it but what he does by sharing all of these details is that, if he has to chuck you to the side, he can easily blame it on his wife rather than have to take responsibility for his choices.
I want to give the guy the benefit of the doubt as someone new to non-monogamy and understand that he very honestly probably does feel at the whim of his partner. It is not unreasonable for him to be anxious about losing his marriage, especially if there are children or assets involved. He very likely feels a tremendous amount of guilt at introducing this bombshell into their lives especially one with no cultural script. And she understandably may feel terrified and scared, maybe even a little hurt and angry by the idea she is not “enough” for him. All of these are valid feelings. But none of these are your responsibility to manage or referee. Not because you have no heart and you don’t care, but because you are not an objective third party and it is actually inappropriate for you to take that role here.
What is fair for you is to ask him to find a therapist to work through his emotions with, for you to ask for what time he can give you, for you to ask if he fully intends on prioritising his wife over you if push comes to shove (and you to decide if that is a risk you are willing to take), and for you to ask for your time spent together to be fun time for your relationship, not a therapy session for what’s going on in his marriage. This may seem cold, especially if you have been socialised as a woman and have constantly been expected to bear the weight of emotional processing for the men in your life, but the quicker more men can learn to not use their romantic partners as their emotional processors, the better. He is capable of finding a therapist to help him out with these feelings. They are capable of finding a couples therapist who can work with them through this difficult period of their marriage. You have done that yourself. He can do that too.
Recenter your attention on yourself and what you need. Not every relationship needs to be for the rest of your lives. Maybe you can accept there is a chance that your relationship may end because he is not willing to risk his marriage and you can enjoy it for what it is. Maybe you are not interested in being the test relationship in this scenario. All of that is way more important than managing what’s going on in their marriage. But understand that just because this feels a little insecure doesn't mean that what feels secure will always be secure.
You could walk away from this situation, find someone who is not dating anybody, then five months down the line they could get into a relationship that is just as volatile. There are no guarantees anyone can give you that everything will be steady and as calm as things may seem at any given point, life can happen and hit anyone hard. Try not to worry so much about how to manage the relationships your partner has with others and focus more on your own internal compass and what you want.
I hope this helps and good luck!